Student savants: Albemarle 3rd graders beat college grads in history smarts

| March 19, 2014 | 6 Comments

by John Ryan

Guest Editorial Graphic Schilling Show BlogSeveral Charlottesville, VA-area elementary schools have filed official public reports that claim from 2011-2013, on average 80% or more of their third-graders pass the Virginia Standards of Learning (SoLs) for historical knowledge.  A closer analysis reveals, however,  that not only is this claim dubious, surveys show that even graduates of America’s top colleges and universities do not possess the historical knowledge that these schools report that four out of five of their 8- and 9-year-olds do.

Virginia’s SoLs for third-graders declare that the student should be able to perform the following tasks (among others), presumably as a condition of graduating to the fourth grade:

  • “The student will explain how the contributions of ancient Greece and Rome have influenced the present world in terms of architecture, government (direct and representative democracy), and sports.”
  • “Describe the individual rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness; and equality under the law.”
  • “Recognize that Americans are… united by the basic principles of a republican form of government and respect for individual rights and freedoms.”
  • “Explain how producers in ancient Greece, Rome, and the West African empire of Mali used natural resources, human resources, and capital resources in the production of goods and services.”
  • “Describ[e] the accomplishments of Christopher Columbus, Juan Ponce de León, Jacques Cartier, and Christopher Newport.”

Note that the SoLs don’t say the student should have to pass a multiple-choice test about these facts and concepts.  Rather, they say the student should be able to “explain” and “describe” them – meaning that one should be able to sit down with a student and say, “Johnny, tell me about the basic principles and origins of our republican form of government that the U.S. Constitution was crafted to facilitate, and how it was influenced by the ancient Greeks and Romans.”

From 2011-2013, Woodbrook Elementary School in Charlottesville, VA, has filed public reports that claim an average of 80% or more of its third-graders pass the VA SoLs for history:

600 25Jan14 Woodbrook 3rd grade history SOL results

Another Charlottesville-area elementary school, Stone Robinson, reported even higher scores among its third-graders on the history portion of the SOLs:

600 31Jan14 Stone Robinson 3rd grade history SOL results

Still another area school, Brownsville Elementary, reports similarly stellar history knowledge among its third-graders.

600 31Jan14 Brownsville 3rd grade history SOL results

The reported achievement of area 3rd-graders, versus numerous surveys of adults and college graduates

Recent surveys, however, demonstrate that the vast majority of America adults, and even college graduates, could not pass the VA SoLs for third-graders:

Our elected U.S. politicians (at all levels) are shown to be even less knowledgeable about history and civics than the general public:

  • Nearly three in ten cannot name one right or freedom guaranteed by the First Amendment.
  • Nearly 80% don’t know that the First Amendment expressly prohibits the federal government from establishing an official religion.
  • More than half are unaware that the Constitution gives only Congress the power to declare war.
  • Less than one-third can correctly describe the free-market system.

Phil Giaramita, the Public Affairs and Strategic Communications Officer of the Albemarle County School system, which governs all three schools, was asked via email to comment on this discrepancy.  His response (in total):

[T]he SOL questions come from the state as does the curriculum and they are the product of a statewide review team of educators.  On occasion, Albemarle County has had a representative on that team but that is not a regular occurrence.

More importantly, we long have had issues with SOL tests in elementary schools, especially in recent years when the tests have required young students to spend up to three hours to complete.  We do not believe that is fair or helpful.  We have had discussions with state legislators about the need to reform SOL tests and there is a proposed change that would eliminate some of these tests.  It’s an encouraging start but hardly sufficient.

The state education department is well aware of our differences with SOLs and our view that there should be alternative assessments that a school division should be able to use.  We did get legislation proposed last year in Richmond that would provided some help but the bill was introduced too late in the session to gain traction.  We will continue to support the need for alternative assessments to the SOL.

In response, the following questions were emailed to him:

According to anyone who looks up the achievement statistics from Albemarle County elementary schools, it makes it appear – on official documents – that four in five third-graders know more about history, economics, civics, political theory, etc. than recent surveys demonstrate that about 98% of adults do, including most college graduates.  Could you please shed light on that issue, particularly?

Also, would Albemarle County be willing to allow a representative sampling of its third-graders to be tested according to the specific criteria of the SOLs, in another environment, supervised by both Albemarle County and independent assessors?

Giaramita did not reply to this email.

Amidst all this murkiness, one fact is clear: it is now up to the citizens of Albemarle County to decide what to do next – whether to (a) accept what would appear to be an egregiously fraudulent academic achievement system, or (b) find a way to put these supposedly super-literate third-graders to the test, and see if they can actually pass what the SOLs dictate.

[This piece originally appeared at The Daily Caller. John Ryan is a nom de plume.]

About the Author:

×

6 Comments on "Student savants: Albemarle 3rd graders beat college grads in history smarts"

Trackback | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Amused Listener says:

    Great! So you guys complain when the schools are sub-standard and then complain when they show evidence of meeting that standard. What’s it going to be fellas? Pick one.

    Giaramita clearly stated the school division’s position on SOL testing – it’s inauthentic, flawed, and a relatively useless tool for measuring academic success. So now you want to give third graders a test to see if they really passed a useless test?

    How about this instead. How about acknowledging that a lot of third grade teachers are working really hard to help kids pass a test that those same teachers know is nonsense merely so that they can maintain the privilege of working with those kids. Recognize that we have a common enemy here and it isn’t the public school teachers. Your energy would be better spent joining with Giaramita and the school division in lobbying Richmond to revamp SOL requirements.

    And if Giaramita isn’t responding to your request, it’s likely because it’s a stupid request and doesn’t deserve a response.

  2. Greer says:

    It’s the evidence that is in question, here. Maybe we should just jail all of the SOL evidence “deniers.”

  3. Ken says:

    And if Giaramita isn’t responding to your request, it’s likely because it’s a stupid request and doesn’t deserve a response.

    Excellent ending to an excellent post. Criticize first, think later is too often the modus operandi here. I’m reminded of yesterday’s gripe-fest about Obama’s response to Putin’s land grab. Not once did the host or the guest say a) what Obama should have done by now or, b) more importantly, what those actions could realistically have had a chance of accomplishing. Identifying a problem is not the same thing as offering a solution.

  4. Rob Schilling says:

    Are Albemarle County 3rd graders smarter than you? Examining Albemarle County's inflated SOL data…

  5. The SOL scores are completely fabricated. Of course, when I heard the fake-scores report on various radio shows a few years ago, I was not surprised. In my radical opinion, who would trust a felon to tell the truth, much less be alone with their kid? Once I learned that cooperating with police to kidnap children so you can have a paycheck is felony abduction, and school is a daytime prison where no student has been convicted of anything, everything started to make sense. Your response– "Oh Blair there you go with that crazy talk again. We've had referendums, laws and court rulings that say it's perfectly legal to force your kid into government custody. You're so stupid. Don't you know when laws conflict, you can pick and choose which laws to follow when you work for government." I guess I'm still mad at public school for not keeping me safe from random gang violence. Oh that's right, felons don't care about your safety. If you love your child, get him or her into a private school where the parent forces the kid to attend, not some armed robot just following orders. But it's not all bad–the school taught me how to read so I could eventually figure out why public school sucks so badly.

  6. Ken says:

    I guess I’m still mad at public school for not keeping me safe from random gang violence.

    I feel your pain. No kidding. Still, if you’re ever able to forgive, you’ll realize that there is no such entity as “public schools.” They’re not all alike. The people who work there are not all alike. Most of them care about kids. Most of them care a lot. Most of the teachers became teachers because they care. Many of them would leave and find better paying work if they didn’t care so much. Yes, the ones at your school failed you. Maybe that’s because someone failed them too. Maybe they’re doing the best they can.

Post a Comment