The Schilling Show has obtained a letter from Virginia Delegate Barbara Comstock (R-34) expressing a number of concerns over the recent arrest of 20 year-old Elizabeth Daly.

Daly, a University of Virginia student was charged with three felonies on the night of April 11, 2013 following her purchase of sparkling water and cookie dough from the Charlottesville Harris Teeter grocery store. Inept Virginia Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC) agents mistook Daly’s water for beer.

Delegate Comstock seeks substantive answers to very specific questions in her July 5 correspondence to W. Curtis Coleburn, III, ABC’s Chief Operating Officer:

This case, as reported, raises a number of issues and questions. I would appreciate if you could clarify some of the questions I have received and give guidance on common practices in these instances:

  1. Why were seven (7) agents at this location and/or required for this arrest?
  2. What are the common practices or procedures for arrest in such a situation? Are there attempts to make arrests in the store after the point of purchase or just outside the store rather than in a dark parking lot where it might be difficult for a customer to determine with whom they are interacting given these officers are in plain-clothes and not uniformed officers?
  3. Are there standard practices and policies for the Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control?
  4. What are the standard policies for use of a weapon?
  5. Considering the facts surrounding this incident—a woman justifiably fearful forher safety who had committed no crime—why were three felony charges filed against her?
  6. What actions, if any, has the Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control taken to avoid future incidents of this nature?
  7. Given the agents were in plain clothes is there an attempt to keep them close to the stores so there is a clear understanding that they are operating in an official capacity?

I understand all of the charges have now been dropped, however this case still raises a number of concerns about a number of practices of ABC in general and if there is a need to change any of the general practices in this area of the law. Given that young women on college campuses could certainly be subject to any number of dangerous situations, it is important to have procedures in place that reflect recognition of those concerns.

Comstock’s letter (full version here) follows The Schilling Show’s news-making release of shocking 911 calls— one from within Daly’s vehicle by passenger, Anne Downey. As the car was being surrounded by armed, plainclothes ABC agents, the girls panicked and fled the scene while Downey talked with the 911 operator. Frightened screams of “Oh my God” and “What should we do?” punctuate the call as Daly attempts to escape agents’ physical assault on her vehicle.

Previous articleExclusive 911 calls: Virginia ABC agent says assault victim “tried to run over people;” witness says “gun was pulled”
Next articleMixed drinks: Who really knew about the Charlottesville ABC takedown
Rob Schilling is founder of the multi-award-winning Schilling Show Blog and News, proprietor of Schilling Show Media; host of both the Schilling Show Unleashed Podcast and WINA's The Schilling Show heard weekdays at noon; husband; father; worship leader, Christian recording artist and Community Watchdog.


  1. Thank you Del.Comstock, for your support for this young woman, who did absolutely nothing wrong. Will you sponsor a bill in the GA to remove the three felonies from her arrest record? Will you request the individuals involved to make a personal apology to the victim (ie, Ms.Daly)? Thanks, JC Maddox, MD.

  2. Thanks for your reporting this Rob. I just sent an email off to Del. Comstock thanking her for her investigation of this scandal. And as Mr. Maddox pointed out, I informed Del. Comstock that Daly's arrest record STILL shows felony arrests.

Leave a Reply