The December 18, 2017 announced “immediate retirement” of former Charlottesville Police Chief Alfred Thomas, was in fact, a deception, foisted on the public by Charlottesville City Hall insiders.

A press release disseminated by former Charlottesville Director of Communications, Miriam Dickler, was unequivocal:

December 18, 2017

Police Chief Al Thomas 
Announces Retirement

CHARLOTTESVILLE, VA – Charlottesville Police Chief Alfred Thomas announced his retirement today after 27 years of law enforcement service. His retirement is effective immediately. A veteran of the United States Air Force, Thomas was appointed police chief in April of 2016 and began his service one month later on May 23rd.    

“Nothing in my career has brought me more pride than serving as the Police Chief for the City of Charlottesville,” said Thomas. “I will be forever grateful for having had the opportunity to protect and serve a community I love so dearly.  It truly has been an unparalleled privilege to work alongside such a dedicated and professional team of public servants.  I wish them and the citizens of Charlottesville the very best.”

“Chief Thomas has served his country and three communities here in Virginia with distinction and honor,” said City Manager Maurice Jones. “He is a man of integrity who has provided critical leadership for our department since his arrival. We wish him all the best in his future endeavors.”

Mr. Jones will formally appoint an interim police chief within the next week. Deputy Chief Gary Pleasants will guide the department until the interim chief is appointed. 

The City will begin its search for a new chief immediately. 

The press release indicated nothing about Thomas remaining on the City’s payroll.

However, a response to a recent open records inquiry tells another story. When asked if Al Thomas was still being paid by the City, Director of Communications, Brian Wheeler replied affirmatively:

From: FOIA <>
Subject: RE: Information Request: Al Thomas
Date: September 21, 2018 at 04:55:42 PM EDT
To: “Schilling, Rob”

Rob – Alfred Thomas is a City of Charlottesville employee with an annual salary of $134,513.60.

Director of Communications
City of Charlottesville

A subsequent request to the tight-lipped Wheeler yielded additional information on Thomas’s ongoing financial relationship with the City of Charlottesville:

From: FOIA <>
Subject: RE: RESENDING FOR RESPONSE #3 Re: Information Request: Al Thomas
Date: September 28, 2018 at 03:33:46 PM EDT
To: “Schilling, Rob” FOIA <>
Cc: “Walker, Nikuyah” “Murphy, Mike” <>

Rob – Alfred Thomas retired from law enforcement on December 18, 2017.  As part of his retirement, Mr. Thomas voluntarily resigned from the Charlottesville Police Department on December 18, 2017 with an effective date of July 15, 2019.  Mr. Thomas was relieved of his duties as Chief of Police on December 18, 2017 and does not hold an active position with the Charlottesville Police Department.  He will continue to receive his former salary as Chief of Police until July 15, 2019.  

One contract exists between Mr. Thomas and the City of Charlottesville.  It is being withheld in its entirety pursuant to Virginia Code Section 2.2-3705.1(1).

This completes the City’s response to this FOIA request.

Director of Communications
City of Charlottesville

When questioned at the December 18, 2017 City Council meeting about the surprise “retirement” announcement, former City Manager, Maurice Jones, stated that Thomas had “volunteered” to step down. In reality, there was unannounced incentive to “volunteer,” and Chief Thomas’s alleged incompetence, in effect, had netted him a $200,000 secret payout, which Jones and Council conveniently neglected to mention.

Compounding the deceit is Wheeler’s curious decision to withhold Thomas’s contract, a move reminiscent of the City’s recently failed attempt to suppress the contract of interim City Manager, Mike Murphy.

The referenced code section justifying the withholding makes clear that employment records are not exempt from disclosure, as contrarily claimed by Wheeler:

2.2-3705.1(1): No provision of this chapter or any provision of Chapter 38 (§ 2.2-3800 et seq.) shall be construed as denying public access to (i) contracts between a public body and its officers or employees, other than contracts settling public employee employment disputes held confidential as personnel records under § 2.2-3705.1

The City publicly parted ways with Chief Thomas just weeks following the release of the report “2017 Protest Events in Charlottesville, Virginia,” authored by former federal prosecutor, Tim Heaphy, and the investigative law practice of Hunton & Williams.

The “Heaphy Report” as it is known, was damning of Chief Thomas, specifically, alleging cover up, misfeasance, and obfuscation, as reported by the Daily Progress:

The review alleges that Thomas attempted to hide material from investigators and intentionally allowed the fighting in and around Emancipation Park on the morning of the rally so that an unlawful assembly could be declared.

Thomas’s attorneys have denied such, on his behalf.

Only in Charlottesville can gross incompetence be rewarded by a massive, covert payout, funded by hapless, non-consenting taxpayers.

Only in Charlottesville can an employee be “retired” and simultaneously hold the same position from which he has “retired.”

And, only in Charlottesville can a “smart, citizen-focused government” uphold secrecy as virtue and transparency as vice.


  1. Essentially, poor policy and bad hires are causing the city who complains about school funding to pay out about four teachers’ worth of salary to no-shows. It is mind boggling to think that a hire like Thomas–good or bad–is worthy of 18 months’ salary paid in full after being on the job for only two years. That tells me that the city has trouble hiring good people.

    This will only get worse as the cavalcade of incompetence reaches Max Bialystock proportions.

  2. This is not socialism. It is alcohol fueled incompetence by Democrats who are incapable of running a 7-11 much less a city. Hey hey ho ho. If you have had enough, it is time to go.

  3. This discussion has to include one question, where in the hell are common sense voters in Charlottesville? This has been ongoing for a long time. Is there not a dynamic conservative voice in C’ville that can energize people to get off their arses and do something about the status quo? I realize the towering presence of UVA and the plethora of left wing activist groups requires a person of Viking determination to stand up to the onslaught but that’s what it takes.

Leave a Reply